We Compare KitchenAid Stand Mixers: Which Is The Best?

kitchen Aid stand mixersThis page is a time-saving one-stop place for you to compare KitchenAid mixers. Find all models here with their features, costs and benefits. Plus, key points to consider when choosing.

After having dug through the maze of information, read hundreds of reviews, contacted the manufacturer, bought and used this brand; we don’t want to leave the pieces just lying around.

We heard you and others like you who either seek clarification or are still confused. So, we pieced everything together in this most detailed KitchenAid mixers comparison. You won’t find anything like this on the web.

What Will You Find Here?

Firstly, have a look through the KitchenAid  stand mixer comparison chart that includes the model you are considering. If you don’t yet have a clear choice, don’t worry.  You will find all KitchenAid mixer models in the charts below.

Charts are great if you want to make a quick assessment at a glance because they are clear, easy to understand and you can compare features side-by-side.

But, what do the data there mean to me? We hear you.  We’re still with you.

We take a closer look at some essential factors which you need to consider. Each factor shall highlight a difference between KitchenAid mixers and shall explain how or why it makes one model better.

If you want our  detailed full review of a certain model, we point you to it.  Where needed, we will recommend articles on this site which you should read.

Cost is an important consideration when deciding which counter top mixer to buy. Approximate costs are included in the tables and we let you know where you can find the lowest cost.

How Are KitchenAid Stand Mixers Classified?

There are two main categories:

  • for home use
  • for commercial purposes.

Models designed for the home are either a tilt head or a bowl lift. These mechanisms are useful for when you need space to scrape content or to manipulate accessories.

Smaller and less powerful models are most often “tilt heads”; whereas the more powerful ones with their bigger motors are “bowl lifts”.

This article which compares a bowl lift vs a tilt head will help you determine which type you prefer.

As we go along, we shall follow the above classifications for clearer presentation and better understanding.

KitchenAid Mixer Models For Home Use

Residential models are designed for preparing food for your family and friends. Some people use the bigger and more powerful models for their home-based businesses. Take note that warranty is voided if you use them for commercial purposes, home-based or not, even if you only produce small quantities.

Tilt Head Models

Lifting the motor head at an angle provides space to mix manually, scrape content or detach or attach accessories. A pin locks or unlocks the head of KitchenAid tilt head models to the stand.

Table 1 displays all tilt head mixers from KitchenAid.  Click on the hyperlinked model names to read full reviews.

Go further down for brief descriptions of each model.

                                          Table 1 – Tilt Head KitchenAid Stand Mixers

FeaturesClassicClassic PlusUltrapowerArtisanArtisan
Design
Priceunder $200 to
$200+
under $200 to
$200+
under $300under $300under $300
Power, watts
250

275300325325
Bread yield, loaves3-3/43-3/43-3/44-1/24-1/2
Cookie Yield, dozens
6-3/46-3/46-3/499
Bowl Capacity, quarts
4.54.54.555
Bowl Type
Brushed SSStainless SteelStainless SteelPolished SSGlass
Bowl Handle
NoNoNoYesYes
Speed Settings
1010101010
Flat Beater and "C" Dough Hook Material
Nylon coated
Nylon coatedBurnished MetalNylon coatedBurnished Metal
Whip6-wire6-wire6-wire6-wire6-wire
Pouring Shield
NoNoNoYesNo
Weight, pounds
2525262629
Dimensions, inches
8-3/4W x 13 15/16H x 14-1/8D
8-3/4W x 13 15/16H x 14-1/8D
8-3/4W x 13 15/16H x 14-1/8D
8-3/4W x 13 15/16H x 14-1/8D
8-3/4W x 13 15/16H x 14-1/8D
KitchenAid Warranty, years
1
1111

Full reviewSee full reviewSee more detailsRead full reviewSee more details

Tilt head KitchenAid mixers are ideal for those who bake for a small family (1-3 kids), prepares small quantities or seldom or don’t make bread

  • The Classic is KitchenAid’s entry level stand mixer. It has the least power. This suits the beginner, the hobby baker or one who is just starting a family.  It is not recommended for bread. Although you might get away with very rare bread making.
  • The Classic Plus is almost the same price as the Classic. But it is more capable of kneading bread dough, although only 1 loaf at a time. At most 2 loaves and not daily. If I want a cheap small KitchenAid I’d pick the Classic Plus over the Classic.
  • The Ultrapower and the Classic Plus perform almost the same. If I want a tilt-head that can make more bread than the Classic Plus, I’d pick the cheapest Artisan over an Ultrapower. The Artisan is slightly more expensive, but it is better for bread dough.
  • The Artisan mixer with its 5-quart bowl and 325 watts power can be used for bread making more often, but not daily. Once or twice a week and 2 to 3 loaves at a time is ideal. 
  • The KitchenAid Ksm150 Artisan is the most popular of all stand mixers in the market for years now. It meets the needs of most families, and is up to the challenge of holiday baking.
  • The Artisan Design Series has a glass bowl with graduations. Aside from being elegant, its other benefit over stainless steel bowls is that you can easily see if there are unmixed ingredients at the bottom.  But a glass bowl is not for someone with weak arms or hands because it is heavy.

Bowl Lift Models

KA heavy dutyThis type has a fixed head that keeps it steady. A crank lever raises and lowers the bowl providing space to access contents and accessories.

There are six distinct groups of Kitchen Aid standing mixers in this category:

  • Professional 5 Plus
  • Professional Heavy Duty (HD)
  • Professional 600
  • Professional 6000 HD
  • Professional 6500 Design
  • Pro Line Series

Then, there are four sub-variants of the Professional 600 line:

  • Professional 600
  • Professional 600 Design
  • Professional 610

Classification Based on Motor Type

We can further classify bowl lift models as to their motor type: AC or DC.

The following have AC motors:

  • Professional 5 Plus
  • Professional Heavy Duty (HD)
  • Professional 600
  • Professional 600 Design Series
  • Professional 610
  • Professional 620

Those with DC motors are:

  • Professional 6000 HD
  • Professional 6500 Design
  • Pro Line Series

You might wonder what’s with an AC or DC motor? Why does it matter?

  • DC motor stand mixers are rated in “horsepower (hp)”, AC motors are rated in watts. DC motors are bigger and heavier.
  • The most crucial difference is that DC motors are excellent at maintaining consistent speed. It does not stall even as the load gets denser or stiffer. As a result, it runs smoothly, is quieter and does not jerk. Therefore, it is better able to tackle tougher mixing and kneading than AC motors.
  • A DC motor also provides greater amount of torque which is the twisting force which moves mixture around. Greater torque is excellent for stiff mixtures like bread, pizza and cookie dough.

See this post which compares benefits and setbacks of each motor type.

Go through the Tables below if you fancy a bowl-lift mixer:

                                Table 2A – Bowl Lift KitchenAid Stand Mixers With AC Motors

FeaturesProfessional 5
Plus
Professional Heavy DutyProfessional
600 Series
Professional
600 Design
Series
Professional 610
Series
Priceunder $300over $300over $300over $400over $400
Power450 watts475 watts575 watts550590 watts
Bread Yield, loaves4-1/24-1/28-1/488 1/4
Cookie Yield, dozens991313
13
Bowl Capacity, quarts
55666
Bowl Type
Polished SSPolished SSPolished SSGlassStainless
Steel
Bowl Handle
YesYesYesYesYes
Speed Settings
1010101010
All-Metal Gear SystemYesYesYesYesYes
Soft StartYesYesYesYesYes
Motor ProtectionYesYesYesYesYes
Electronic Speed SensorYesYesYesYesYes
Flat Beater Material
Nylon CoatedBurnished
Metal
Burnished
Metal
F Series CoatedBurnished
Metal
"PowerKnead"
Spiral
Dough Hook
Nylon CoatedBurnished
Metal
Burnished
Metal
F Series CoatedBurnished
Metal
Whip
6-wire6-wire6-wire6-wire11-wire
Pouring Shield
NoNoYesBowl CoverYes
Weight, pounds
2929293432
Dimensions, inches
11 5/16W x 16 1/2H x 14 5/811 5/16W x 16 1/2H x 14 5/811 5/16W x 16 1/2H x 14 5/811 5/16W x 16 1/2H x 14 5/811 5/16 W x 16 1/2 H x 14 5/8 D
KitchenAid Warranty, years
11111

More detailsSee full reviewSee full details

                                 Table 2B – Bowl Lift KitchenAid Stand Mixers With DC Motors

FeaturesProfessional
6000 HD
Professional
6500 Design Series
Pro Line Series
Priceunder $300over $500over $500
Power1.0 hp1.0 hp
1.3 HP
Bread yield, loaves
8 1/2
Cookie Yield, dozens
14
Bowl Capacity, quarts
667
Bowl Type
GlassPolished SS
Bowl Handle
YesYesYes
Speed Settings
101010
All-Metal Gear System
YesYesYes
Soft Start Feature
YesYesYes
Motor Protection
YesYesYes
Electronic Speed Sensor
YesYesYes
Flat Beater Type
Nylon coatedF-Series CoatedBurnished Metal
"PowerKnead Spiral" Dough Hook
Nylon coatedF-Series CoatedBurnished Metal
Wire Whip
6-wire6-wire11-wire
Pouring Shield
NoBowl CoverYes
Weight, pounds
313432
Dimensions
, inches
11 5/16 W x 16 1/2 H x 14 5/8 D
11 5/16 W x 16 1/2 H x 14 5/8 D
13 1/4 W x 16 1/2 H x 14 3/14 D
KitchenAid Warranty, years
115

See full detailsClick fore more detailsSee more details

Let’s go over some important considerations for comparing the bowl lift stand mixers listed  on Tables 2A and 2B:

  • All are equipped with Soft Start feature, Motor Protection and Electronic Speed sensor. The tilt-head models don’t have these features.
  • Soft Start feature starts the mixer slowly even if you accidentally set it on a higher speed at the start. This is important because it prevents splatters and  flour cloud which reduces the mess you’d have to clean up.
  • Motor Protection shuts off the motor when it becomes overloaded. Some folks get annoyed when this happens. But, it essentially prevents your mixer from going bust which results from overworking the motor.
  • Electronc Speed Sensor runs the mixer at a consistent speed for proper mixing and dough formation.
  • The Professional 5 Plus is in the price level of the tilt-head Artisan, but has 125 watts more power making it superior for difficult dough.
  • The Design Series models have glass bowls with graduations and F-series coated beater and dough hook. A glass bowl is elegant but also heavier which may not suit those with weak hands and arms. KitchenAid’s proprietary F-series coating does not chip like nylon-coating or oxidizes like burnished metal.
  • The Professional 620 has metallic finishes. It is similar to the tilt-head custom metallic model.
  • The Pro 6000 Heavy Duty, Pro 6500 Design and the Pro Line have powerful DC motors.
  • The Pro Line series comes with a 5-year warranty compared to 1 year for the rest. That is how confident KitchenAid is with the Pro Line.

See full info

What KitchenAid Mixers Are Made For Commercial Use?

KitchenAid offers two types of stand mixers for commercial use: the 7 quart and 8 quart models. They have identical features and accessories…

  • 1.3 hp DC motor
  • J-hook handle on the bowl for better control
  • Metal gear casings
  • A heavy duty 48” long power cord
  • Certified for commercial use
  • Stainless steel accessories: flat beater, spiral dough hook and 11-wire elliptical whip.

                       Table 3 – Commercial KitchenAid Stand Mixers

click map

The 8-quart model has two variants:

  • KSM8990 has no bowl guard
  • KSMC895 includes a metal bowl guard that swings up and out

The bowls are interchangeable. However, the 8-quart model is taller and there is more space between the head and the bowl. Hence, the clearance is reduced if you use an 8-quart bowl on the 7-quart model.

What Are The Available KitchenAid Mixer Colors?

One of the big selling point of  a Kitchen Aid stand mixer is the wide array of lovely delectable sounding colors. However, this is not true for all models. Most are available in only 3 – 5 shades.

kitchen aid stand mixers

  • The Artisan series  with 40 gorgeous shades is on top, followed by the Professional 600 with 24.
  • The Artisan Design series comes in 13 different vivid and glossy shades.
  • The most common colors across all models are: Empire Red, Black and White.
  • A pink KitchenAid mixer is the most sought after. So is a red one.
  • Other popular shades are: green, yellow, ice blue, cobalt blue, teal, pistachio, purple and cranberry.

Is There A Refurbished KitchenAid Mixer?

Most of the refurbished units on Amazon are 5-qt. Artisan mixers and 6-qt. Professional 600 series. Some carry a warranty period of 90 days to 6 months.

Refurbished units undergo strict testing and quality control before they are certified by KitchenAid.

You can save anywhere from 25% to 40%  on a reconditioned unit.

Where To Find the Best Price on KitchenAid Mixer

Cost will be a big factor in  picking a stand alone mixer  from this popular brand because it is a substantial investment. You will want to find a KitchenAid outlet that offers the lowest prices.

If you have made a choice and are ready to buy a KitchenAid mixer, better check Amazon because their prices are still the cheapest. In fact, for the most part of 2016, they do not vary much from those of the sale seasons of Black Friday, Cyber Monday and Christmas.

Even with KitchenAid coupons, rebates, etc., most stores can’t beat prices on Amazon.  

At least one store gives rebates and a form of store cash which you can use to purchase other items from them. Another popular outlet offers discount on your next purchase over a certain amount. My problem with this discounting schemes are:

  • Firstly, I will be forced to purchase items from the store even if they sell at higher prices than in other stores.
  • Secondly, I will be forced to buy things I don’t need just so I can use the store cash or the discount.
  • Thirdly, some or most of us have a budget, we don’t wanna spend now on things we may need later via store cash or discount privileges.

I prefer to hold any savings I can get in “cold cash”. That way I have control over what to do with what I’m able to save.

Ready to buy a KitchenAid mixer? Go back to the Tables and click on your preference to see product details.

Which KitchenAid Mixer Is Best?

We come to the point of determining which really is the best KitchenAid stand mixer. There is no single criteria because almost all the time it will depend on one’s needs, preferences and budget.


best kitchen aid mixer

But, from extensive research, there are indeed certain models that perform better and are more efficient.

Let us summarize the essential points from the Tables and discussions to make it easier for you to decide. We shall be considering needs as our main criteria:

  • The hobby or beginner baker will pick the Classic Plus. It’s 4.5 quart capacity is just right. It is cheaper but slightly more powerful than the Classic.
  • The Artisan series is ideal for most household needs including Holiday baking. It can cater to a family of 4-6. Plus, you can make bread infrequently (once or twice a week) with it.
  • If you are more than 6 in the family and would like to be able to make bread daily, consider  a Professional 600 or a Professional 6000 HD. It has bigger capacity and higher power than the 5-quart models.

Tip

If cost is not an issue, it’s best to grab a model with a DC motor because it is far more superior. Below are your 2 best choices:

The Pro Line series works well for both small and big quantities. If the 7-quart bowl is too big for you, 3-quart and 5-quart bowls are also available. The Pro line offers more leeway with it’s powerful DC motor. If bread making is your primary use of a stand mixer, this is the wisest choice for home use.

A cheaper DC motor mixer is the Professional 6000 HD.  And, its 6-quart bowl and 1 hp motor is not an overkill for those who don’t prepare big amounts.

If business is your primary purpose, get  a commercial model.

KitchenAid stand mixers for the home, except those with DC motors, have almost the same issues.

If you read online discussions about which KitchenAid standing mixer is good, you’ll notice that most revolve around the capacity for handling heavy dough.

Now, why do some people claim that a certain model is good for bread, while others complain. Most likely it’s because several factors affect dough consistency. Protein content, baker’s percentage, humidity, other ingredients (nuts, grains, etc.), volume, speed and time will determine how difficult a mixture is.

Whatever your considerations are when weighing which KitchenAid stand mixer is for you, it is worth taking note that it’s better to have excess capability now than need more later and not have it.

In Category: KitchenAid
Show 0 Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a Comment