A good stand mixer is quite a big investment. It’s not something that most of us can buy anytime. Some of us have to save hard for a really good model that we hope will last us for years. Before we pick one, we research models and features because we want them to serve us well.
When it comes to how you can access the bowl, attachments and accessories of a stand mixer, there are two options for you. It’s either a tilt head model or a bowl lift model. It’s good to know what each option offers and how they differ so that you know exactly what to expect and to prepare for.
There seems to be some confusion when it comes to these two options. One owner of a high-end model submitted a review saying that she is disappointed because she cannot lift the head. Well, it’s because she got a bowl lift model.
What Is a Tilt Head Stand Mixer?
As the name implies, you can tilt the mixer head. The head of some KitchenAid stand mixers tilts from where the head and the stand join, just on top of the stand. You have to unlock the head before lifting and lock it before operating.
Cuisinart’s tilt head mixers tilt from the middle of the stand. Its stand mixers are usually shorter. Consequently, the space between the head and the bowl is smaller.
[yellowbox]Check this Big Saving on the Artisan 5-quart Tilt Head Stand Mixer[/yellowbox]
What purpose does tilting the head serves? It is needed when you attach and remove the bowl, beater, whip or hook. It is almost impossible to do them with the head down because there is very little room to maneuver.
A tilt head is also handy when you want more room for scraping and mixing the contents by hand, or when adding ingredients.
What Is a Bowl Lift Stand Mixer?
Bowl lift stand mixers are taller. Its head is fixed. The bowl is held by two clamps on either side. It is raised and lowered by turning a crank on the side of the stand. Lifting the bowl will bring it into contact with the beaters. Lowering it will give space to attach and remove accessories and to access contents of the bowl.
Comparing Tilt Head and Bowl Lift Models
It’s easier to attach, change and remove accessories in tilt head models. Batter that clings to the beater drips down better when the head is tilted because of its slanting position. It’s also easier to scrape off sticky batter from the beater.
Tilt head models require less vertical space when not in use, so it’s easier to find room for it under cabinets. You can just pull it out when you’re going to use it if there is not enough space.
The lifting mechanism, however, presents a drawback. Because there is a hinge, the head has a tendency to vibrate. Take the KitchenAid tilt head mixers. There are several reports that the pin that holds the head to the stand tends to loosen causing the head to bob, especially with thicker and heavier mixtures.
Removing beater, whip or hook in a bowl lift stand mixer can be a bit awkward. When you pull them to detach, you do so vertically down. That will usually mean dipping the beater on the batter again, especially, when the bowl is full. It can get messy.
Bowl lift stand mixers are taller and require more vertical room.
Bowl lift models are steadier because the head is not hinged to the stand. More powerful mixers with bigger motors and bigger capacity are usually bowl lift models. The KitchenAid Pro Series 6-quart, 575 watts motor stand mixer is a bowl lift. You cannot find a KitchenAid 6-quart with a tilt head. Cuisinart have 7-quart, 1000 watts tilt head models, though.
One satisfied owner of a KitcheAid Pro shares that his dream is to have a Pro with a tilt head. I asked my husband, an engineer, why more powerful stand mixers are bowl lift types. His opinion: it’s most probably a design consideration because more power means a heavier motor. The designers deem it better to keep a big head fixed.
Very helpful. Best article I’ve read on the subject. Thank you.
There have been people who have complained of hand injury accidents (some severe) from the tilt-head type. I have been looking around to see how common it is. That would be enough for me, who tends to be kitchen accident prone, to be slightly inconvenienced by the lack of ease concerning beater-access or countertop cabinet clearance. Thank you for this article. All good points and very helpful!
That was really helpful. I’ve only had the lift model before (on a now 30 year old 4 1/2 qt mixer) which just died. As I tend to use it for bread doughs and virtually never for soft stuff like meringues, I’ll stick with what I’ve had. I don’t need a vibration disaster where it walks off the countertop.
do you know if the 6500 model has the same clearance from bottom of bowl to beater as the 600 series. I don’t like the fact that the beater doesn’t go all the way to the bottom of the bowl. Makes it very hard to beat small amounts of ingredients like whipping egg whites.
Hi Teresa,
Beater to bowl clearance will depend on your adjustment. I have a Pro 600. When I was adjusting the height with the whip attached, I got one adjustment whereby the whip hit the bottom of the bowl and I had to raise it a bit. I have had no problem beating egg whites. That being said, I prefer using my hand mixer for one egg white.
Cheers,
Renee